Twin Cities Housing Inventory Down vs. Last Year

Since early this year, the Twin Cities housing market has been making strong gains towards a level of what I call “peak inventory.” What I’m describing as peak inventory is the point where we see the number of houses for sale today at a level lower than last year. Well, we officially hit that in the weekly market report dated 5/5/2008 and are continuing that trend the last two weeks as well.

What does this mean? There’s approximately 600 fewer homes for sale today than there was a year ago and if current trends continue as they have for the last few months, we could be down more than 1000 listings by early June. At the same time, Pending Sales are still averaging approximately 12% behind last year’s numbers, meaning that while supply is down slightly, average market times are still 16.7% higher.

What do I like about this data?  Well, even though market times year over year are still higher, if we continue to reduce inventory at the clip we have the most recent months, we will find market times start to fall as well.  Yes, this could be some time in coming, but market times can only fall if there’s a huge surge in demand or a significant drop in supply.  While most agents would say they’d rather see more sales, I’m perfectly happy to accept dropping supply… what we’re looking for is balance to come to this market as quickly as possible… there seems to be a lot of people “waiting to see what happens” before they decide to do anything.

While this is a good sign, it will be MONTHS before this trend of falling year-over-year inventory makes any significant difference.  The next good sign would be when Days on Market year-over-year begins to fall as well, as this would demonstrate that the market is truly absorbing the inventory faster than it is accumulating.

Re-listing Homes: Not Unethical

In February, a local real estate agent did an interview for Nightline and came off very badly.  What his intent is to refresh the property so that the buyer gives it another consideration.  He is correct that when buyers see that a home has been for sale for a long time, they immediately think something is wrong with it.  However, counting simply days on market does not take into account these things that might have affected its previous ability to sell:

  • Time of year – homes sell slower in the winter months
  • Price – if the price was reduced 10% yesterday, it is on Day 2 of it’s current price
  • Updates – seller may have done cleaning/updating/staging since first listing
  • Failed sale – if it sold once in 45 days and the sale fell through, it is almost like starting over.

As a great friend of mine in my office always says: “the first time a buyer sees a house is Day 1 on the market for that buyer.”  I have to agree in that homes are unique enough and in this market homes for sale are high enough that a single buyer makes all the difference.  If a buyer has never looked at the home before, what difference does it make to them how long the home was for sale before they ever saw it?  If everyone else didn’t like the house, they better not like it either?????

Next time you go shopping at a department store, ask the sales clerk how long that shirt has been for sale on the rack… and if it has been on the rack more than 30 days, ask for a 10% discount on the shirt!  Maybe that shirt isn’t the most popular color or size or maybe it was priced too high and is now on sale, or maybe it wasn’t very visible on the rack at first.  No matter it’s history, if the shirt is a color you like, fits you well, and at a price you’re willing to pay, I bet you’re going to buy the shirt.  Same thing goes for the house!

While I fully support the concept of re-listing properties at the discretion of the seller/listing agent, but I also believe that any and all activity must be disclosed upon request from a buyer/buyer’s agent.  Further, no agent should advertise selling a home in XX days when it is really XX + XX days.

The Minneapolis Area Association of REALTORS does publish market stats with CDOM (Cumulative Days on Market) so I believe we’re tracking correct numbers in the Twin Cities, so I do not believe it is hurting our market picture.

In the end, a number of days on market means nothing unless you fully understand how that number came to be… re-listing a home is simply another marketing tool used to get a buyer to come to you with enough interest to give you the time to explain the situation.

Equal Housing Opportunity and REALTOR logo

TwinCitiesRealEstateBlog.com is not a Multiple Listing Service MLS, nor does it offer MLS access.
This website is a service of Aaron Dickinson of Edina Realty, a broker Participant of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota, Inc.