2010 Twin Cities House Prices – Fall Forecast

Twin Cities Median Sales Price – All Properties

Median Sales Price- Twin Cities - All Properties

(image courtesy Minneapolis Area Association of REALTORS)

What does the fall and winter 2010 hold for Twin Cities home prices? If the last couple years are any benchmark, we should see median sales prices drop substantially… most likely back to the $155,000-$160,000 range that we have seen the last two years.  The fact that buyer activity has slackened since the expiration of the tax credits and our very seasonal market make this a pretty safe bet to make.

It is important to keep in mind that Median Sales Price can be useful but also deceptive – it doesn’t take into account the type, size, condition or location of the properties that are selling – it just looks at what has sold in the month and picks the price that is in the middle of all those sales prices.  A lot of what sells in the cold months are houses that must sell for reasons like relocation, foreclosure, estates, etc.  Many sellers are “fair weather sellers” that aren’t desperate to sell and therefore take their house off the market in the colder months or simply do not aggressively drop their price to sell.

In fact, when separating Median Sales Price out by traditional sellers, foreclosures (bank owned), and short sales we find that there really isn’t nearly as much variability as what the composite numbers show:

Median Sales Price by Type of Sale


(image courtesy Minneapolis Area Association of REALTORS)

Will Median Sales Price drop this winter? Yes.  Will actual home values drop this winter?  If history and seasonality hold true, yes… but not as much as what some of the market statistics will make it look.

2009 – The Year of Multiple Offers in the Twin Cities

When I became a Realtor in December of 2002, the housing market was already on its long march up to levels that no one thought possible.  By 2005 we had hit the peak of the market but 2006 was still extremely strong too.

One of the things that’s been largely missing since 2005/2006 is the situation where several buyers are interested in the same house.  We did see this phenomenon in 2008 with short sales but that was mostly due to the long time it could take for responses from the bank (3 weeks to 3 months in many cases) providing a huge window of time for buyers to submit offers.

2009 started much the same way but since approximately March 1st we’ve seen a huge increase in buyers in the market and with that, many more multiple offers.  In the last 45 days I’ve been in multiple offers on the following:

  • A foreclosed home in Coon Rapids that had 3+ offers
  • A foreclosed home in South Minneapolis that had 13 offers
  • A foreclosed home in Shakopee that had 6 offers
  • An estate in Coon Rapids that had 2 offers

These were all properties that I had buyers write offers on… if you count all the houses that my buyers had wanted to see that we skipped due to the multiple offers already submitted or already having an accepted offer and I’d say it was about 1 in every 3 houses on their list.

My experience has been that these multiple offers are strongly clustered on short sales, foreclosures and estate sales as these are the sellers that have the most motivation to price properties to sell quickly.  The occasional Traditional Seller still garners multiple offers (much more so this year than last) but many of these sellers are still pricing properties slightly (or sometimes drastically) above market value so their demand is understandably less for many buyers today.

The Minneapolis Area Association of Realtors released March market statistics last Friday that help explain why our market is seeing more multiple offers today than we have seen in several years:

  • Prices have fallen substantially since 2005/2006
  • Interest rates are near all-time lows
  • The Housing Affordability Index has hit ALL-TIME HIGHS
  • Inventory of homes for sale is down 17.5% from this time last year
  • The number of houses available per buyer is down 23.5% from this time last year… a 2+ year low!
  • Pending Sales (accepted offers on their way to closing) are up 18.6% so far this year

Supply Demand Ratio - April 2009

Combine all those data points together and it is easy to see why there could be strong buyer competition for the best houses (in terms of total VALUE, not PRICE alone) and given that our buyer activity typically stays strong into July I predict we’ll see many more multiple offers in the coming weeks and months.

Minneapolis Area Association of REALTORS Monthly Video Update

Take a look at some great commentary by MAAR.  The numbers are clearly showing a peak of inventory and a bottom for buyer demand, so we see “strength” in numbers that are no longer continuing to soften.  This market has a long way to go before we’re back to “normal” but it all has to start with supply, demand, and affordability… all of which are looking better today than they did even a few months ago.

Here comes statistics in a video

Jeff Allen @ the Minneapolis Area Association of REALTORS,�my good pal after the months of working on the Lender Mediated Sales Report together, has started what looks to become a once-a-month summary video of the highlights from the MAAR reports.  Granted the info discussed is all the positive stuff, but hey, that’s what a good marketing campaign is all about.

Equal Housing Opportunity and REALTOR logo

TwinCitiesRealEstateBlog.com is not a Multiple Listing Service MLS, nor does it offer MLS access.
This website is a service of Aaron Dickinson of Edina Realty, a broker Participant of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota, Inc.