Twin Cities Home Sales Climb 10% !!!!

After six months of lower year-over-year pending sales numbers, the Twin Cities has finally posted an improvement in sales activity.  The week ending 12/4/10 saw 606 pending home sales versus 551 in the same period a year ago, which is an increase of 10% from the prior year’s figure.  Pending sales are properties that have accepted offers but have not yet closed.

You’ll notice that each week there’s been an improvement in year-over-year comparisons and that is partly due to the artificial demand we saw last year when the tax credit was originally set to expire.  This week’s sales increase is pretty good news in and of itself but what is even more interesting to me is that sales for the week ending 12/4 in 2010 looks to have been the strongest showing for that week since 2006!  While it isn’t a huge jump in sales in comparison to prior years, it is still a small improvement.  What is striking is how consistent the sales have been since the expiration of the tax credit:

Weekly Pending Sales

While the numbers are not huge, they have been consistent and that is reassuring – no matter the circumstances, a certain number of homes will be bought and sold and this leveling in demand says to me that we’ve found that fundamental level.  An early review I did of pending sales for the week ending 12/11/10 shows sales just about where they were the same week last year, which would make it the 2nd best week in comparison to the prior year since the tax credit expiration.

The housing market is far from recovered but at least it’s reassuring to see an occasional positive indicator like we did this week.

Twin Cities Buyer Activity Still Down 40% Vs. Last Year

Twin Cities home buyer activity is still substantially lagging last year at this time.  For the last 5 consecutive months we’ve seen home showing activity down approximately 40% versus the same time last year.

Twin Cities Showing Activity
Twin Cities Showing Appointments

How well do showing appointments correlate with sales?  Very, very, very well.

Since showings happen before offers (usually!), they provide us a little bit of a leading indicator into future sales activity.  Pending homes sales have been down about 40% each week since mid-May and showing activity really slowed the last week of April, which suggests about a 3 week lag time before the Pending numbers reflected the diminished showings.  Since most properties are only Pended after inspections have been completed and the listing agent turns in all the paperwork, this lag time seems reasonable.

Twin Cities Pending Sales

What does all this mean for us?  Well it looks like the coming weeks will continue to see Pending Sales down significantly from last year.  What I find a little comforting is that while buyer activity is down significantly, it has been very consistently hovering at the same level for the last 5 months… to me that suggests we are at a fundamental level of home sales activity…  before a market can climb it has to hit bottom, right?!?!

Twin Cities Home Sales Plummet

The fallout from the tax credit expiration continues to be felt by home sellers, agents, home inspectors, loan officers and appraisers – showings and Pending Sales are both down about 40% versus the same time last year!
May 2010 Home Showing Stats

(data prior to April 2009 is not complete)



Twin Cities Homes for Sale - Pending Sales

This is certainly not surprising – many of the buyers that would have bought later this year had great incentive to make an offer earlier in the year.  What remains to be seen is what happens with home sales after this bad hangover is over.  When the statistics for the last week of May are released next week I suspect we’ll see the same tepid activity – I know it was pretty quiet in my office last week!

1000's of Pending Home Sales may be Missing from MLS Reporting

The Minneapolis Area Association of Realtors has a fantastic assortment of stats that are published on weekly, monthly, quarterly and yearly cycles.  These reports are based off the listing data provided by our local MLS, the Regional MLS of Minnesota.

As anyone who works with data knows, the statistics you create are only as good as the data underlying it – also known as: “garbage in, garbage out.”

The RMLS has several different statuses for MLS listings like: Active, Pending, and Sold.  As anyone in the housing market today knows, many homes listed as “Active” are really “Pending” because they have an offer accepted subject to inspection or in the case of REO (bank owned) & short sale homes, they often have multiple offers on them already.  Because our MLS does not have a status for “Active with Offer,” Realtors and consumers have a hard time finding out what properties are truly available until the agent sets up a showing – a very frustrating and time consuming process.

Luckily, some Realtors have been adding to their MLS remarks fields information about listings being “sold subject inspection” or “short sale offer accepted- backup offers only.”

MLS Shadow Pendings Example

On Monday  I looked at these remarks fields and searched for terms used to describe accepted offers subject to inspection, multiple offers, and offers subject to bank approval.  What I found was that there are 884 listings that are currently marked Active but look to be “Pending.”  Of these 884 listings, 675 were short sale and an additional 50 were bank owned, making a total of 82% of these shadow pendings “lender mediated.”

In my experience, more listings are never updated with these kind of remarks than are, so it is quite possible that more than 2000 listings that we see as available inventory are really not.

While the data that MAAR is currently publishing is entirely accurate based on the data they are provided, this clearly shows that there’s more activity happening than is currently reported- which to any buyer or agent in the field right now matches perfectly with our experiences.

Equal Housing Opportunity and REALTOR logo

TwinCitiesRealEstateBlog.com is not a Multiple Listing Service MLS, nor does it offer MLS access.
This website is a service of Aaron Dickinson of Edina Realty, a broker Participant of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota, Inc.