Twin Cities Housing Forecast: It’s November in June!


(image courtesy MAAR)

The anemic Twin Cities Pending Home Sales figures posted the last 5 weeks are both expected as well as disappointing.  While us REALTORS all knew that things post-tax-credit would be slower, I for one am rested and ready to really get back at it.  If we compare pending home sales since the expiration of the tax credit with historical sales for the same period, we find that the most recent weeks are more typical of November than June.  That chill on sales activity is certainly being felt.  I have heard stories from agents of some houses not getting a single showing for more than a month and sellers getting nervous and frustrated.

The cold front that has come through the Twin Cities housing market has certainly been noticed by sellers and agents alike, and by buyers too.  The buyers I have looking for houses today are finding better selection and less competition, leading to a more relaxed home search and buyers confident that they will find the right home for them… eventually.  This buyer relaxation directly correlates to a lack of urgency though, and that leaves many sellers barely on this side of sanity as they wait for a buyer to approach them with an offer.

While it may be cool in the Twin Cities housing market right now, the recent dramatic change in pending sales is still nothing compared to what we see in our weather and isn’t even close to record lows.  If I were to take the job of a housing market weatherman, I would predict that the Twin Cities housing market this summer will be cooler than normal with both some weeks of sunshine and rising www.s (as sales start to rebound) and some occasional stormy clouds (more foreclosures, short sales) as well.  Fall’s weather is going to be dependent on the housing market equivalent of El Nino – if we see unemployment and consumer confidence improve we may see more warmth in the market.  However, if we do not see improvement in the economy we may be in for another cold and long winter.

May 2008 Twin Cities Market Stats

MAAR has released their new market stats for the month of May and I’m trying a new idea: I’ve added commentary to the report expressing what I believe are the important “take aways” from the data.  I would love to get feedback both on the concept and your thoughts of my opinion.

Minneapolis/St. Paul Real Estate Market Stats for May 2008 with commentary.

Q&A – How to Spot a Recovering Housing Market

I hear buyers, sellers, lenders, real estate agents and the community as a whole rhetorically ask when we’ll see the housing market recover.  Unfortunately putting a timeline on a housing recovery is pretty unrealistic as there are simply too many variables to account for.  But all is not lost!  While I cannot predict when the housing market will recover, I can give you trends to watch for that will signal a turnaround and their current indicators.

Falling Inventory
Supply & Demand 101: if demand has fallen sharply, supply must also fall sharply to keep prices in line.  Supply in the Twin Cities is still near record highs, so it must come down significantly.  The trend is certainly going the right direction (inventory is falling +/- 200 listings per week vs. last year) but this improvement is still minor and early at this point.
Trend: Positive

Falling New Listings
So far this year we’ve seen 9.5% fewer new listings come on the market versus the same time period last year, which has www.ered total active listings this year.
Trend: Positive

Increasing Sales
The supply problem can also be resolved by more buyers coming in to the market.  As of May 1, we’re still 12.6% behind last year in the number of Pending Sales year to date, so this indicator still needs improvement.
Trend: Negative

Falling Days on Market
Ultimately we will see the market times of listings fall, but in April it still took on average 154 days to sell a home in the Twin Cities… an increase of 16.7%.
Trend: Negative

Flat Median Sales Price
When we see the sales prices year-over-year flatten, it will show we’ve reached a price stability level and encourage more buyers back into the market.  In April our median sales price was down 7.9% from a year ago, so we’re not there yet.
Trend: Negative

Fewer Foreclosure and Short Sale Listings
While it is clear that foreclosures and short sales are different animals from Traditional Sellers, they do have a strong influence on the housing market direction and we need to see them reduce in both number and market share before we can see a strong turnaround.  These listings are still coming on strong and while their number and market share hasn’t changed much in recent months, they still account for slightly more than 1 in 4 sales in the Twin Cities.
Trend: Negative

Low Mortgage Rates
Mortgage rates still continue to bounce between approximately 5.75% – 6.25% on a 30yr fixed rate, which is still phenomenally low.  As long as these rates stay below 7%, buyers will have strong buying power in this market. If rates climb above 7%, buyers will pull back hard.
Trend: Positive

More Flexible Financing Options
I’m not talking about the return of subprime, I’m only talking about more options for borrowers with little/no down payment.  Fannie Mae reversed their position on “declining markets,” FHA is looking at lower down payment requirements, more risk-based pricing options coming back… while it isn’t going to be the world of free money like it was before, financing options seem to be improving.
Trend: Positive

Increased Market Optimism
Markets are often self-fulfilling prophecies… while the general public (and the media) are still down on the real estate market, the market will continue to perform badly.  This is something that only time and continued good news can cure.
Trend: Negative

The Return of the Professional Investor
I’m seeing and hearing a lot more about investors lately… more so than I have for at least a year or two. The Professional Investor will go out and cherry-pick the best inventory even if a market bottom hasn’t been called… they know a good deal when they see one.
Trend: Positive

Equal Housing Opportunity and REALTOR logo

TwinCitiesRealEstateBlog.com is not a Multiple Listing Service MLS, nor does it offer MLS access.
This website is a service of Aaron Dickinson of Edina Realty, a broker Participant of the Regional Multiple Listing Service of Minnesota, Inc.